Sunday, January 21, 2024

The Oligocene dolphin Xenorophus, part 1: introduction to Xenorophus sloanii and the Xenorophidae

In November I published a rather massive monograph on the fossil dolphin Xenorophus - it's my longest publication to date (166 pages!), and my third published monograph - and one of two published in 2023* (check out my blog summary of my other 2023 monograph on Coronodon here, here, and here). This series of posts will be in four parts: 1) an introduction to Xenorophus sloanii and the family Xenorophidae; 2) new specimens of Xenorophus sloanii; 3) the new species Xenorophus simplicidens; and 4) the paleobiology of these dolphins and some of what we've learned about them. Click here for part 2, and here for part 3 on Xenorophus.

*I am very tired.

The Discovery of Xenorophus sloanii 

Paleontology in Charleston had an early start - likely owing to the combination of the plantation economy (lots of digging activity) and some of the earliest correctly identified fossil vertebrates from North America in general were found by enslaved Africans on the Stono Plantation in the mid 18th century and identified by them as elephant teeth - later revised to mammoth teeth. During the antebellum years, other finds made by the enslaved and slaveowners include the holotype skull of the Oligocene dolphin Agorophius pygmaeus and the Eocene basilosaurid Dorudon serratus. After the Civil War, the phosphate mining boom resulted in a proliferation of fossil discoveries and widespread stratigraphic confusion that took another century to untangle (see my earlier blog post on the Ashley Phosphate Beds here).


 The holotype skull of Xenorophus sloanii, collected from the Ingleside Mining Pit near Ladson, South Carolina, sometime before Kellogg's (1923) publication.


 My own photograph of
Xenorophus sloanii - from a 2016 visit to USNM collections with Morgan Churchill and Sarah - just after our colleague Dr. Rachel Racicot's wedding a few miles away!

The mining boom had died down by 1890 or so, but a few marl pits continued operating into the early 20th century. One such pit, the Ingleside Mining Pit*, yielded an unusual cetacean skull sometime before 1923 and was acquired by Earl Sloan, the state geologist, who subsequently donated to the Smithsonian for Remington Kellogg to study. Kellogg named the skull Xenorophus sloanii** in 1923 after Sloan just three years before Sloan passed away. The specimen was clearly from the "Cooper Marl" - now known as the Ashley Formation. Kellogg recognized that this specimen represented an early odontocete, which he referred to as a "dolphin" and noted archaic features such as double rooted multicuspate teeth and retention of an intertemporal constriction. However, he also noted that this skull had a very unusual lacrimal bone, and premaxilla. The lacrimal is the bone that houses the tear duct in terrestrial mammals; in most marine mammals the duct is lost and the bone just forms the anterior part of the orbit. In most dolphins, it is relatively small and forms the anteriormost part of the orbit - but is also fused to the jugal bone, stretched into a delicate bone the thickness of a toothpick. Instead, in Xenorophus, the lacrimal is large and triangular and covers the entire front half of the orbit - but on the dorsal side. In most other odontocetes, the dorsal part of the orbit is typically formed by ascending process of the maxilla. Xenorophus also has an ascending process of the maxilla - clearly making it an odontocete. The premaxilla, on the other hand, is also quite strange. In a normal odontocete, the premaxilla forms the tip of the snout, bears a few teeth, forms the middle of the snout (housing the mesorostral groove/gutter) and then wraps around the left and right sides of the blowhole. The premaxilla does all of these things in Xenorophus - but also invades the entire part of the skull between the eye socket and the blowhole and has a large, posteriorly expanding cone-shaped body that is actually exposed ventrally just behind the eye socket where the frontal bone has a large ring-shaped window in it. Normally the premaxilla is a thin plate that lies atop the maxilla around the nares - but in this case, the opposite is true: the maxilla instead lies above the premaxilla. The premaxilla basically occupies a space in the skull normally 'built' by the frontal. All of this is just bonkers-ass crazy, even for dolphins, which already have bizarre skulls. But we're not done: the inflated part of the premaxilla here is also osteosclerotic - extremely dense.

*Coincidentally, on the property of the Ingleside Plantation, the plantation of Francis Holmes - former curator of the College of Charleston Museum and the guy who started the phosphate mining boom - and discoverer of Agorophius.

**Commonly misspelled sloani, but the correct spelling by Kellogg shows it as sloanii. 


 The holotype maxilla fragment of Squalodon pelagius - as figured by Leidy (1869).

Other Early Discoveries of Xenorophidae

Famed American paleontologist Joseph Leidy was a contemporary of Francis Holmes, who sent a small rostrum fragment with a single tooth (found along the Ashley River) to Leidy. Leidy published the specimen in his 1869 monograph, naming it Squalodon pelagius. Leidy almost certainly used the genus Squalodon here as a wastebasket owing to the occurrence of double-rooted triangular teeth. He also noted the presence of what we now call embrasure pits - pits to accommodate the opposing teeth. These pits are unique to the family Xenorophidae, and I think this specimen compares quite well with Echovenator and Albertocetus (see below for more on these taxa). Unfortunately, the specimen is now lost.

 The mysterious skull of Archaeodelphis patrius, from Miller (1921) - my scan of a copy of Ed Mitchell's personal copy of the paper with his labeling and highly distinctive writing - which he had provided to Ewan Fordyce (long before all that Llanocetus nonsense).

Another curious specimen was 'discovered' in the collections of the Museum of Comparative Zoology at Harvard around World War 1 and named Archaeodelphis patrius by prominent mammalogist Grover M. Allen. This specimen consists of a braincase somewhat resembling Xenorophus, but with an orbit that is only partially covered by the ascending process of the maxilla - uniquely 'primitive' amongst all fossil odontocetes.* Like Xenorophus, this specimen possesses an intertemporal constriction and a relatively untelescoped skull. However, it doesn't quite have the same sort of highly inflated premaxilla. Archaeodelphis patrius has been needing redescription and reinterpretation for a century - and for the past half century, was locked away in a loan cabinet - while many researchers have considered it one of the most important fossil odontocetes ever discovered. OK, but here's the rub: we have no idea where the damned thing is from or how old it is. In general, the skull "looks" like an Oligocene dolphin - only Oligocene dolphins are as archaic in their morphology. A similar specimen at Charleston Museum, ChM PV 4746, was collected from the Chandler Bridge Formation of South Carolina - but the morphology is an inexact match. Unfortunately, during 100 years of collecting, not a single perfect match has been found - which is admittedly a little bit of a problem, as most of the taxa we have here - named or unnamed - are known by at least a couple of specimens (however, ChM PV 4746 is an exception and is still a singleton). Still, Charleston seems likely for several key reasons: it's the only place in the southeastern USA where fossils of archaic odontocetes were being routinely found in the 19th century. The skull was likely part of the collection Agassiz was studying and at some point divorced from its documentation (and never labeled). Holmes and Leidy never wrote about such a specimen - but perhaps it was discovered late in the 19th century (post-Leidy?) by someone in Charleston and whoever committed the information to memory either died or forgot it, and the skull sat in MCZ collections for some time prior to being 'discovered'. Finding a new Archaeodelphis would really be something.

*I very strongly suspect that the holotype of Archaeodelphis is a juvenile, however, and some of this may simply be ontogenetic recapitulation of archaic to derived features.


 The holotype skull of
Albertocetus meffordorum, whitened with ammonium chloride - the skull is nearly black in color. It is much closer in morphology to Xenorophus than it is to Echovenator or Cotylocara. From Uhen (2008).

 

Size comparison of Albertocetus and Xenorophus. Modified from Uhen (2008).

 

Skull, endocast, earbones, vertebrae, and skeletal reconstruction of Albertocetus meffordorum - images from Boessenecker et al. (2017B).

A North Carolina xenorophid: Albertocetus

Onslow Beach in coastal North Carolina has long been a location where fossils have been found strewn along the water line. In the early 2000s, several dolphin-bearing concretions were discovered and sent to the Smithsonian. I saw a talk by Mark Uhen in 2006 at the Neoceti symposium at the SVP meeting in Ottawa (my second SVP ever!) reporting these archaic specimens - and in 2008, Uhen published a paper naming Albertocetus meffordorum, the first xenorophid named in 90 years. Like specimens from the famous "Emlong collection" at the Smithsonian, this specimen had to be carefully prepared out of a hard calcareous nodule using air scribes. Albertocetus has a similar facial region to Xenorophus, and a braincase that looks - well, a lot like an archaeocete whale. Critically, it also preserved the first good earbones for the Xenorophidae - a periotic is preserved in Archaeodelphis, but it was not well-figured. Later, in 2017, I reported new specimens of Albertocetus from the Ashley Formation of Charleston - demonstrating that this taxon lived in both the Charleston and Salisbury embayments during the Oligocene - hardly a surprise. These specimens also preserved earbones removed from the skull and associated postcrania.

The skull of xenorophid Cotylocara macei from the Chandler Bridge Formation of South Carolina, from Geisler et al. (2014).

 
The holotype skull of Cotylocara macei on display at my former institution - the Mace Brown Museum of Natural History - and a 3D model of the skull with some of the bony sinus fossae on the skull.

Xenorophids and the origin of Echolocation: Cotylocara and Echovenator

Shortly thereafter witnessed a flurry of papers on xenorophid dolphins from Charleston, South Carolina. The first of these made it into the journal Nature - likely to be the highest profile publication to ever come out of the College of Charleston (very curious). The study, published by Jonathan Geisler et al. (2014), named the new genus and species Cotylocara macei - the holotype of which, CCNHM 101, is the first published specimen from my old institution, the Mace Brown Museum of Natural History at the College of Charleston. Cotylocara macei is clearly a xenorophid, though it has a much narrower snout than Xenorophus, and a wider, dish-shaped facial region. It also has a somewhat more telescoped skull - barely having an intertemporal constriction at all, with the facial bones thrusted posteriorly and overriding most of the anterior part of the braincase. However, it is distinctive in possessing a large pit behind the blowhole, which Geisler et al. named the postnarial fossa. Additionally, the specimen has very well-preserved antorbital fossae, noted previously but not interpreted. These large facial fossae are further lined with low-density bone similar to that lining the air-filled sinuses of extant odontocetes. This suggests that Cotylocara had considerable air-filled sinuses in its facial region, likely connected to diverticulae in the highly modified blowhole and indicating the ability to produce high frequency sounds used in echolocation. However, CT scans of the cochlea of Cotylocara were not informative at the time to confirm whether or not these sounds could be heard. 

 
Travis Park with the North Carolina xenorophid periotic reported by Park et al. (2016) and a modern delphinid periotic - specimen subsequently reidentified as Echovenator.
 

 
The skull, mandible, atlas vertebra, and earbones of Echovenator sandersi - from Churchill et al. (2016).
 

Life restoration of Echovenator sandersi - by Alberto Gennari.

 

 

Comparison of periotics of Albertocetus from the Ashley Formation of Charleston SC (A-B) and Belgrade Formation of NC (C-D; collected Gary Grimsley in 2016), the North Carolina Echovenator periotic studied by Park et al. (E-F; collected J. Mefford, Onslow Beach NC), and a periotic of cf. Echovenator I collected from Belgrade Quarry in 2017 (G-H) - from Boessenecker et al. (2017B).

High frequency hearing was later confirmed in xenorophid dolphins by two studies that came out in parallel: Park et al. (2016), who scanned an isolated periotic of a xenorophid from Onslow Beach (North Carolina - same site as Albertocetus), and Churchill et al. (2016), who reported another xenorophid, Echovenator sandersi, from the same rock unit as Cotylocara - the Chandler Bridge Formation of South Carolina. The North Carolina periotic had evidence of adaptations for hearing high frequency sounds, but was unidentifiable (at the time) past the family level. The beautifully preserved skull of Echovenator sandersi, on the other hand, had some similar, but more subtle facial sinus fossae like Cotylocara, and well-preserved periotic bones. Morphometric analysis of the scans indicated that Echovenator could hear high frequency sounds; between these two genera, xenorophids in general were clearly able to echolocate. Ironically, Park et al. (2016) and Churchill et al. (2016) were unaware that the other team were working on the same taxon: a year later, I published an article reporting the periotic morphology of Albertocetus, and in it reidentified the North Carolina specimen as Echovenator sp. owing to numerous shared features. 

The partial holotype skull (and referred specimen - E) of the dwarf, snort-snouted toothless suction-feeding dolphin Inermorostrum xenops - from Boessenecker et al. (2017A).

My life restoration of Inermorostrum xenops.  

 Rostral proportions through time in Odontoceti - Inermorostrum is already one of the most brevirostrine odontocetes, and it evolved within just a few million years of the mysticete-odontocete split. From Boessenecker et al. (2017A).

A xenorophid that really sucked: Inermorostrum

One of my first projects at CCNHM was to report this adorable little skull clearly representing an adult dwarf xenorophid. This skull has a vertex with similar skull sutures to Albertocetus, and shared with it and Xenorophus a flat vertex - in other words, lacking the postnarial fossa of Echovenator and Cotylocara. While the small size is distinctive, that pales in comparison to the business end of the skull: the snout is quite short - approximately 1/3 of the length of Cotylocara if you scale it to the width of the snout - and completely toothless. That is not to say the teeth fell out - there are no tooth sockets, either - indicating that the species was completely toothless. We named this new genus and species Inermorostrum xenops - the genus name meaning 'weaponless snout' and the species name meaning strange face, hearkening back to Xenorophus itself and the family. This little dolphin was from the Ashley Formation, a contemporary of Albertocetus and Xenorophus and about 28-30 million years in age; only a single referred specimen exists, a partial vertex in Charleston Museum collections. Analyses of rostrum length evolution through time indicated that longirostry (long snouts) and brevirostry (short snouts) evolved many times in parallel within the Odontoceti, and that xenorophids evolved short snouts very, very early in odontocete evolution, shortly after diverging from the baleen whales. What good is a short, toothless mouth? Reduction of the dentition has occurred in many modern odontocetes including sperm whales (Physeroidea), beaked whales (Ziphiidae), Risso's dolphin (Grampus griseus), and the narwhal (Monodon monoceros). In all such cases, the few teeth that are retained are generally reserved for combat and not used in biting prey. Most also happen to have short snouts. Many toothy dolphins with short snouts also exist. What these all share is the ability to suction feed for soft-bodied prey like squid and fish. The loss of teeth accomplishes two things: streamlines the mouth to improve the flow of water, and in the case of those species that feed on squid, decreases hard points that suckers can attach to easily. A short snout makes for a smaller mouth, which if paired with large lips, increases suction forces as well. The tiny size of Inermorostrum means that it was also a shallow, rather than deep diver: this rules out deep dives for squid. Perhaps Inermorostrum was coastal in its distribution (like most small odontocetes today) and foraged on the shallow sea floor for soft bodied prey like sea cucumbers, octopus, and worms.


A family portrait of Xenorophidae - from left to right: Xenorophus sloanii, Cotylocara macei, Echovenator sandersi, and Inermorostrum xenops.

In sum, many new xenorophids have been discovered since Kellogg named Xenorophus sloanii in 1923 - but that's obviously not all that's been uncovered. Next up in Part 2, I'll review the new specimens of this new species and some of what we've learned.

References 

Allen, G.M. A new fossil cetacean. Bulletin of the Museum of Comparative Zoology 1921, 65, 3-14.

Allen, J.A. Note on squalodont remains from Charleston, S.C. Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History 1887, 12, 35-39. 

Boessenecker, R.W.; Fraser, D.; Churchill, M.; Geisler, J.H. A toothless dwarf dolphin (Odontoceti: Xenorophidae) points to explosive feeding diversification of modern whales (Neoceti). Proceedings of the Royal Society B 2017A, 284, 20170531

Boessenecker, R.W.; Ahmed, E.; Geisler, J.H. New records of the dolphin Albertocetus meffordorum (Odontoceti: Xenorophidae) from the lower Oligocene of South Carolina: encephalization, sensory anatomy, postcranial morphology, and ontogeny of early odontocetes. PLoS ONE 2017B, 12, e0186476.

Churchill, M.; Martinez-Caceres, M.; Muizon, C.d.; Mnieckowski, J.; Geisler, J.H. The origin of high-frequency hearing in whales. Current Biology 2016, 26, 2144-2149.

Geisler, J.H.; Colbert, M.W.; Carew, J.L. A new fossil species supports an early origin for toothed whale echolocation. Nature 2014, 508, 383-386.

Kellogg, R. Description of an apparently new toothed cetacean from South Carolina. Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections 1923, 76, 1-7.

Park, T.; Fitzgerald, E.M.G.; Evans, A.R. Ultrasonic hearing and echolocation in the earliest toothed whales. Biology Letters 2016, 12, 20160060. Uhen, M.D. A new Xenorophus-like odontocete cetacean from the Oligocene of North Carolina and a discussion of the basal odontocete radiation. Journal of Systematic Palaeontology 2008, 6, 433-452.

Saturday, January 13, 2024

Some recent advances in late Cenozoic shark paleontology

When I first started out in paleontology as an undergraduate in the mid 2000s, I had a background in fossil sharks. I collected shark teeth in high school and they ultimately got me hooked on marine mammals. However, it seemed like most of the publishing effort on fossil sharks at the time, and up until 2014-2015, had focused chiefly on Mesozoic through Eocene sharks and the study of Neogene (Miocene, Pliocene; 23-2.6 Ma) sharks was quite stagnant. One major exception at the time was the hallmark publication by Purdy et al. 2001 in Lee Creek Volume III, on the fossil sharks, rays, and fish from the Pungo River Limestone and Yorktown Formation. However, it feels that recently - since the start of the pandemic - the publishing rate on Neogene sharks has exploded - especially as regards the megatoothed sharks. There are more papers on Carcharocles megalodon in the past five years than the prior thirty (estimate, I'm too lazy to actually count - though I suspect that's actually going to be a conservative figure). So, I figure it's about time to cover some of this territory.

Lamniform sharks (plus Squatina, Hexanchus, and Pristiophorus) from the latest Miocene-late Pliocene aged Purisima Formation in California - from Boessenecker (2011), the first paper I ever wrote, and one of the first ones I ever published.

I started working on my first paper reporting fossil sharks in fall 2006 - eventually submitted sometime in 2010 and published, of all days, on the day of my wedding to Sarah in 2011 (only about an hour before we left for the venue). This paper (Boessenecker, 2011) in Palarch's Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology reported fossil sharks, skates, bony fish, and some sea bird remains from a formely unstudied locality in the Purisima Formation, and focused on a bunch of fossils I had collected. I had a firmer grasp of the identifications and morphology of the non-mammals, and the marine mammal remains would have to wait. 

While I was in college, not much was published on mid-late Cenozoic sharks - but I'll briefly list some of the more salient articles. Sylvain Adnet et al. (2006) published an interesting study documenting body size changes in the cow shark Hexanchus through geologic time. Somewhat later, Adnet et al. (2010) reported an unusually large fossil great white shark tooth from Spain suggestive of larger body size in the past. The tired argument regarding whether or not C. megalodon was related to great whites was finally addressed in a morphometric analysis by Nyberg et al. (2006), who found that it is not very similar to Carcharodon carcharias. Catalina Pimiento et al. (2010) reported a Carcharocles megalodon nursery assemblage from the Miocene of Panama and followed it up with a pretty impressive study of the entire shark fauna from the same locality (Pimiento et al., 2013). The infamous "transitional" great white shark dentition from the Pisco Formation of Peru was finally described by Dana Ehret et al. (2009) and shortly thereafter formally named Carcharodon hubbelli (Ehret et al., 2012). Christy Visaggi and Stephen Godfrey (2010) published a survey of shark teeth from Calvert Cliffs in Maryland, comparing ex-situ teeth found on the beach with teeth found in situ from the cliffs and examining issues like collections bias. 

Research seemed to pick up a bit during my Ph.D. program (2011-2015). Bruce Welton returned to publishing after his retirement and published some papers on fossil basking sharks, including naming the archaic genus Keasius (Welton, 2013). The extinct megamouth shark from the Oligocene of Pyramid Hill, California, was finally named as Megachasma applegatei (Shimada et al., 2014). A number of shark assemblages from South America, Central America, and the Caribbean were reported (Aguilera et al., 2017; Carillo-Briceno et al., 2016; Carillo-Briceno et al., 2016; Carillo-Briceno et al., 2015; Carillo-Briceno et al., 2015; Staig et al., 2015; Carrilo-Briceno et al., 2014). Jurgen Kriwet et al. (2014) named a new genus for Isurus/Cosmopolitodus escheri, placing it in Carcharomodus. Perhaps the most important study published in the interim was by Kent (2018), who reported the shark and ray fauna of Calvert Cliffs in Calvert Cliffs Volume I. Most critically, and perhaps preceding the recent flourishing of research on Neogene sharks, was a flurry of articles on megatoothed sharks including a statistical analysis supporting a relatively recent extinction for Carcharocles megalodon (Pimiento and Clements, 2014), a study of body size change in Carcharocles (Pimiento and Balk, 2015), the naming of a new dwarf megatoothed shark Megalolamna (Shimada et al., 2016), a study of paleogeographic distribution of Carcharocles megalodon (Pimiento et al., 2016), and a report of long-forgotten C. megalodon teeth from California and a comprehensive reanalysis of its extinction (supporting a much older, "mid" Pliocene extinction) by yours truly (Boessenecker et al., 2019).

This blog post will focus on summarizing some of (but certainly not all) of the papers since the Covid-19 pandemic started that report new occurrences, assemblages, and findings on Neogene sharks - and Oligocene sharks as well (since Oligocene assemblages have more in common with Miocene than Eocene assemblages). If I've missed something you'd like me to include, please let me know in the comments and I'll consider updating the article!

Examples of fossil sharks and the rarefaction analysis from Chavez-Hoffmeister and Villafana (2022).

Shark Assemblages

Chavez-Hoffmeister and Villafana (2022) report an aggregate fossil assemblage of sharks and rays from three different formations along the northern coast of Chile - the Coquimbo Formation, La Portada Formation, and the famous Bahia Inglesa Formation (near Caldera, Chile). The study is more of a checklist and identification guide than a formal description of a chondrichthyan assemblage - but that's actually the goal of the study. The study acknowledges the extractive role of illegal fossil digging in Chile that led to large numbers of shark teeth being sold, without provenience, on the black market. Fortunately, this has slowed considerably and permitted Chilean researchers to actually collect specimens with stratigraphic data. For context - there is considerable confusion as to the stratigraphic record of Carcharodon carcharias within the Bahia Inglesa Formation, no doubt a cause of the 1) poor stratigraphic control over the years and 2) poor collection of stratigraphic data by illegal fossil diggers. This study also used a rarefaction analysis to estimate how many additional species may await discovery, suggesting that only 3/4 of the fauna had been detected.

Oligo-Miocene sharks from Ecuador, reported by Carillo-Briceno et al. (2020).

An assemblage from the Oligocene-Miocene boundary (~23 Ma; Montanita-Olon) of Ecuador was reported by Carillo-Briceno et al. (2020). Like other Pacific assemblages covered elsewhere in this post, there's much more in the way of deep water sharks present, including Heptranchias, Centrophorus, Echinorhinus, Mitsukurina, and Pristiophorus. Some of the regular suspects are present as well - Carcharocles chubutensis/angustidens, Carcharias, Odontaspis, Parotodus, Carcharhinus, Galeocerdo, Alopias, Hemipristis, etc. This study reports many new records for the Tropical east Pacific and South America.


The sample of Carcharocles angustidens teeth from the original Chandler Bridge excavation, along with our reconstructed body length curves - clearly dominated by juvenile sharks. From Miller et al. (2021).

In 2021 my student Addie Miller, Matt Gibson (natural history curator at Charleston Museum), and I published a paper reporting an assemblage of Carcharocles angustidens teeth from the Chandler Bridge Formation here in South Carolina. The teeth are from a location where only we had access (and given my frequent visits, there were very few if any folks who snuck onto the property). Mostly all we found were small teeth. Addie reconstructed the body sizes from each tooth by identifying the likely tooth position, plugging each measurement into a different tooth-by-tooth set of equations developed earlier by Kenshu Shimada for great white sharks. Then, she generated a size distribution curve - and determined that nearly all of the specimens were from individuals that were only half grown in body size or smaller. She also did the same for a larger assemblage of teeth from the original Chandler Bridge excavation, briefly mentioned in a 1996 book chapter by Bob Purdy - and duplicated the results. Two different localities in the same rock unit, a couple of miles apart, collected nearly 50 years apart by different researchers! These results indicate that the Charleston Embayment was likely used as a nursery area by megatoothed sharks in the Oligocene. 

 Analysis of body size distribution in Carcharodon carcharias teeth from  three different localities in the Pliocene of South America: Pisco Formation of Peru, Coquimbo and Caldera in Chile - from Villafana et al. (2020).

Another nursery area was reported by Villafana et al. (2020) for the extant great white shark (Carcharodon carcharias) from the Coquimbo Formation of Chile. Teeth from the Pisco Formation of Peru and the Bahia Inglesa Formation further north at Caldera (Chile) are dominated by subadults and adults. This is the first well-documented nursery area for Carcharodon carcharias in the fossil record, and I suspect many more have yet to be identified and studied.

Fossil sharks from the lower Miocene molasse of Switzerland, reported by Villafana et al. (2020).

A diverse assemblage of sharks from the early Miocene aged Achen Formation in the Molasse of Switzerland was reported by Villafana et al. (2020). This assemblage includes 37 taxa, some of which are deep water species like Chlamydoselachus, Notorhynchus, Squalus, Deania, Isistius, Mitsukurina, Scyliorhinus, Pachyscyllium, Paragaleus, and Chaenogaleus. Other more typical shelf-inhabiting (or otherwise shallow water) sharks like Alopias, Carcharias, Carcharhinus, Squatina, Galeocerdo, Physogaleus, Sphyrna, Rhizoprionodon, Myliobatis, Rhinoptera, Dasyatis, and others.

Fossil sharks from the Liuchungchi Formation of Taiwan, from Lin et al. (2022).

Lin et al. (2022) report a rare example of a shark assemblage from the early Pleistocene - and better yet, from an unusual location: Taiwan. Owing to low sea level in general and the repeated and rapid changes in sea level, Pleistocene marine vertebrate-bearing fossil assemblages are quite rare because they are either underwater, never deposited, or have been completely eroded away. In this case, there are abundant specimens of Carcharodon carcharias, and some of the first Pleistocene records of Hemipristis serra from the Pacific basin - now completely extinct.

 Sharks from the Duho Formation of South Korea - reported by Malyshkina et al. (2023).

A somewhat older shark assemblage from another unusual western North Pacific location - the Duho Formation of South Korea - was reported by Malyshkina et al. (2023). They report a mixed pelagic and deep marine assemblage including kitefin sharks (Dalatias), cow sharks (Hexanchus), basking sharks (Cetorhinus), makos (Isurus sp. 1 and 2, Cosmopolitodus hastalis and "Isurus" planus), megatoothed sharks C. megalodon and Parotodus benedeni, a bunch of reef sharks (Carcharhinus spp.) and a tiger shark (Galeocerdo aduncas). 

Shark and ray teeth found ex situ on beaches of the northeastern Gulf coast (MI/FL) - from Clinton et al. (2023).

An ex-situ assemblage was reported from the coastline of Mississippi and the panhandle of Florida by Clinton et al. (2023). These fossils are likely from Pliocene and Pleistocene marine strata - several different formations are possible sources. These teeth were all collected by beachcombing - picking up fossil teeth on beaches on the Atlantic and Gulf coasts is a very popular hobby. I've found a single tooth this way on the Pacific coast, and thousands here in South Carolina alone; about 700 such teeth were reported from this survey. Taxa include the usual suspects for the southeast: Carcharhinus, Negaprion, Galeocerdo, Rhinoptera, Aetobatus, and others.

New specimens of the tiny megatoothed shark Megalolamna paradoxodon from the Miocene Maryland (A-H) and Oligocene of South Carolina (I-M), from Shimada et al. (2023).

More on Carcharocles megalodon and friends

Just last week, Kenshu Shimada, Victor Perez, Bretton Kent, and I published a new article reporting new records of the tiny megatoothed shark Megalolamna paradoxodon from the Miocene Calvert Formation of Maryland and the Oligocene Chandler Bridge Formation of South Carolina. The first is a first record for the state of Maryland, but the second extends the range of Megalolamna well into the Oligocene epoch (though I'll note that one specimen from the Jewett Sand at Pyramid Hill is from right around the Oligocene-Miocene boundary, and the locality has been considered to be of Oligocene age in the past and only recently revised).

Growth lines in the vertebra of C. megalodon - from Shimada et al. (2020).

A couple of papers from 2020 dove into the life history and body size of C. megalodon. The first of these by Shimada et al. (2020) studied the growth of C. megalodon using growth lines in a vertebra from an associated set of vertebrae from the Miocene of Belgium. The first growth band was laid down at a relatively large size, indicating a size at birth of about two meters! Enormous babies like this indicate that C. megalodon likely achieved such large fetal sizes through intrauterine cannibalism - one fetal shark swimming around inside the uterus for quite some time and eating successive rounds of eggs - such in some extant mackerel sharks. Another study by Shimada et al. (2020) evaluated recent hypotheses of 'regional endothermy' from prior studies of body size modeling. Shimada et al. reconstructed the maximum body length of C. megalodon at about 14.5 meters (~48 feet). Endothermy has previously been hypothesized for explaining gigantism in C. megalodon and other lamiform sharks - but Shimada et al. point out that this may have been in turn driven by live birth and intrauterine cannibalism.

Possible life reconstruction of Carcharocles megalodon based on the allometry of modern lamniform sharks - from Cooper et al. (2020).

A recent study by doctoral student Jack Cooper and colleagues (2020) produced a new two dimensional reconstruction of the body proportions of C. megalodon. They studied the proportions of the fins and tail throughout growth (allometry: change in proportions during growth) of five modern mackerel sharks including great whites (Carcharodon), both species of makos (Isurus), and two species of Lamna, in order to predict what the proportions would be in such a gigantic shark. Based on these predictions, they hypothesized that C. megalodon was a rapid, active swimmer. However, this was recently criticized by Sternes et al. (2022) given that none of this was based on actual fossil data. Sternes et al. further highlighted a lack of correlation between body form in lamniform sharks and their thermophysiology, suggesting a limited implication of these models on understanding the life history and behavior of C. megalodon. Modeling is great, but in this case I feel like it was pretty far divorced from what we can actually know from the fossils.


Nursery assemblage of juvenile C. megalodon teeth from Spain and other assemblages from around the world - from Herraiz et al. (2020).

A short paper by Herraiz et al. (2020) reported several nursery assemblages of C. megalodon from around the world, including a new assemblage from Spain - but also the Calvert Formation of Maryland, Bone Valley Formation of Florida, and the Chucunaque Formation of Panama. Each of these assemblages was found to be dominated by juvenile sized teeth. This study generated a response by Shimada et al. (2021), who indicated that some degree of this might be influenced by latitude, with larger individuals possibly inhabiting higher latitudes, and smaller individuals at lower latitudes - an example of Bergmann's Rule.

3D modeling of the body form of C. megalodon by Cooper et al. (2022).

This was shortly thereafter revisited by Cooper et al. (2022), who did a somewhat more data-based approach and attempted to reconstruct the 3D body form of C. megalodon based on a known set of associated vertebrae from the Miocene of Belgium and also an attempted reconstruction of the cranium and jaws based on a fossil tooth set of C. megalodon from the USA and scaling up the cartilaginous chondrocranium of a great white shark. The results surprisingly differ quite a bit from the reconstruction by Cooper et al. (2020), as the pectoral and tail fins seem quite a bit smaller than the prior reconstruction. Again, acknowledging that there is an enormous amount of wiggle room here is being overly modest: we don't know what the body of C. megalodon looked like and likely never will, and I'm not certain how repeatable this is. However, another study did report new fossils that can actually test this...

Representative examples of placoid scales from the Japanese C. megalodon specimen, from Shimada et al. (2023).

Another recent study by Kenshu Shimada et al. (2023) weighed in on the recent controversy over the ecology of C. megalodon by reporting the first assemblage of placoid scales (denticles) from the species. One of the few specimens of C. megalodon consisting of associated teeth that had been competently collected is an associated tooth set reported in the late 1980s from the Miocene of Japan. One of the preparators of the specimen had the foresight to save large samples of matrix from the specimen. Kenshu asked for the matrix and screened through it - revealing a spectacular assemblage of 589 (!!!) scales, from only about 30 cubic centimeters of matrix. They also report a number of cartilage fragments. The individual carilaginous tesserae (prisms of prismatic cartilage) are the same size and structure of regular-sized modern sharks, indicating that gigantism in sharks does not require an increase in the size of the tesserae. The placoid scales of this specimen are noteworthy because they give us some unprecedented information about the swimming speed of C. megalodon - scale morphology in sharks is generally linked to their life habits. Scales are generally similar in morphology to mako sharks, but large in size and comparable to some pelagic carcharhiniforms like blue sharks (Prionace) and reef sharks (Carcharhinus). Analysis of the distance between keels on the scales suggests that C. megalodon was actually a somewhat slow cruising swimmer with the occasional burst of speed.

A manganese oxide-encrusted C. megalodon tooth from the deep sea floor reported by Pollerspock et al. (2023).

A new study by Pollerspock et al. (2023) reports the first discovery of a C. megalodon tooth found in situ on the seafloor. Many such specimens have been reported over the past 150 years, including specimens found on the expedition by the HMS Challenger - but all previous examples were dredged from their context. This specimen was found by an ROV on the top of a seamount at a depth of three kilometers (still quite deep!). These authors point out that the coastal ecology of C. megalodon inferred from the fossil record may be biased towards deposits above sea level, and that future discoveries from the deep sea might adjust these hypotheses somewhat.
 

Mediterranean specimens of the "false mako" Parotodus benedeni from Collareta et al. (2023).

A more obscure paper on "the other megatooth" - Parotodus (aka false mako) - was published just a few months ago by Alberto Collareta et al. (2023)* - this study reports new specimens of Parotodus benedeni from the Pliocene of Italy and took the opportunity to review the state of knowledge of the paleobiology of this species. They indicate a maximum body size of around 7 meters (roughly 20-22 feet), support a pelagic (open ocean) lifestyle for this shark owing to its rarity in shallow marine deposits, and likely very different feeding ecology as compared to its bigger cousin C. megalodon given the stouter unserrated teeth and relatively limited pattern of tooth breakage/chipping - perhaps suggesting feeding on soft prey such as rotting whale carcasses (a very Hornerian style hypothesis, a la scavenging T. rex).

*funny story, I've been talking with Kenshu Shimada about some proposed research on this shark, and when I ran into him the first day of the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology conference he asked me if I had read the most recent paper on it. "No?", I responded. He said "Wait, I've got a paper copy, I just finished reading it" and handed me a printout. I did not recognize the title and so I looked for the publication date - "Kenshu, this was published yesterday! There's no way I would have seen it!" We had a good laugh about it and he gave me the copy, which I read on the elliptical after I got home to Charleston.


Noteworthy studies reporting one or two taxa


 Late Miocene sharks from South Korea reported in various papers by Yun (2020, 2021).

A number of fossil occurrences of sharks from South Korea were recently reported by Yun (2020), Yun (2021), and Yun (2021) including the ancestral great white Carcharodon hastalis, "hooktooth mako" Cosmopolitodus planus, goblin shark Mitsukurina lineata, and kitefin shark Dalatias licha. In one of these papers, Yun formally transferred the species Isurus planus to Cosmopolitodus, a genus that was originally designated for the species Isurus hastalis. Yun disagreed with the placement of 'hastalis' within Carcharodon (e.g. Ehret et al., 2009), and stuck it back in Cosmopolitodus - the genus for the broad toothed makos. Owing to the similarity with C. hastalis, 'planus' was also transferred to this genus. Additionally, see Malyshkina et al. (2022) above.


The oldest known Cosmopolitodus planus specimen, early Miocene, Sakhalin, Russia - from Malyshkina et al. (2023).

Malyshkina et al. (2023) report the oldest known specimen of Cosmopolitodus planus, the extinct and poorly understood "hooktooth mako" as it's called in California. This species is widely known from the Pacific coast of North America, particularly from Sharktooth Hill; I've collected many such specimens from there and the Santa Margarita Sandstone near Santa Cruz. Additional records are known from Japan and Australia (and New Zealand; sea below!). Unfortunately, whether this occurrences is from the earliest or late early Miocene is unclear as the deposits in Sakhalin and Kamtchatka require considerable further stratigraphic study.

The first records of Carcharodon hubbelli and Carcharodon planus from New Zealand - from Ehret et al. (2023).

A recent paper (that actually came out shortly before Malyshkina et al., 2023) by Dana Ehret, Marcus Richards, Alan Tennyson, and myself reported some specimens of sharks including the first records of Carcharodon hubbelli and Cosmopolitodus planus from New Zealand. The record of C. hubbelli is noteworthy as it has previously been reported from Peru, California, Japan, and perhaps Australia - further suggesting a Pacific-only transition for the great white, followed by a dispersal to other ocean basins like the Atlantic, Mediterranean, and Indian oceans. The new records of C. planus further illustrate a similar Pacific basin distribution - though we note the lack of this species from the Pacific coast of South America. In this paper, we further acknowledged the similarities between "planus" and "hastalis", and formally transferred "planus" to Carcharodon, forming the new combination Carcharodon planus. We also reported the oldest known specimen of this species that is well-dated, and very possibly older than the Sakhalin specimen above - one specimen from the Kaipuke Siltstone has an age determination of lower Waitakian, corresponding to Aquitanian and a likely age of 22.7 Ma (earliest Miocene).

Thresher sharks (Alopias, left) and mackerel sharks (Lamna, right) reported from Bahia Inglesa, Chile by Villafana et al. (2023).

Another similar paper by Villafana et al. (2023) reports the first fossil records of the porbeagle shark Lamna nasus and thresher shark Alopias vulpinus from the Neogene of South America. These specimens were collected from the Bahia Inglesa Formation near Caldera in Chile. This is the first report of the genus Lamna in the fossil record of the Americas, and one of only a few records - period.

 
Mediterranean Pliocene specimens of Carcharodon carcharias and presumed changes in food webs since the Pliocene, from Collareta et al. (2023).
 
A short paper by Collareta et al. (2023) reviews the record of Pliocene great white sharks (Carcharodon carcharias) from the Mediterranean. This study synthesizes fossil and molecular data, highlighting an arrival of the species sometime in the earliest Pliocene and more recent dispersal (~3 Ma) from an ancestral Australian/Pacific stock for the current population. A review of tooth size in Pliocene Italian specimens suggests considerably larger body lengths in the past versus modern shark specimens. The loss of many 'medium sized' whales in the Mediterranean during the Pliocene-Pleistocene transition suggests that great whites have weathered some major trophic changes - perhaps corresponding to a decrease in body size.
 

Comparison of teeth of Isurus subserratus (A-D), Carcharodon carcharias (E), and Carcharocles megalodon (F), from De Schutter et al. (2021).
 
In addition to the transitional great white Carcharodon hubbelli from the upper Miocene of the Pacific, there is also "Isurus" escheri from the mid-upper Miocene of the eastern North Atlantic - a narrow-toothed mako-like form with faintly serrated teeth. This species was recombined as Carcharomodus escheri a few years ago by Kriwet et al. (2014). A new study by De Schutter et al. (2021) reports new specimens of this taxon from the mid-upper Miocene of the Netherlands. However, they point out that Isurus subserratus and Isurus escheri were named on the same page of Agassiz (1843 - page 260), but subserratus was named earlier on the page - and therefore technically has priority over escheri. So, they sweep both Carcharomodus and escheri under the rug and synonymize everything with Isurus subserratus. Teeth of Isurus subserratus have much finer serrations than anything in the Carcharodon lineage, and start out narrow like shortfin mako teeth, and become gradually broader and more similar to Carcharodon in successively younger strata - and the authors group these from different horizons into Type 1, 2, 3, and 4. Unfortunately, many of the specimens (plates 5-6) reside in a private collectin (and, IMO, should not have been published upon).


Geologic range of "valid" (bold) and "invalid" species of Galeocerdo, and a comparison of Galeocerdo aduncas (A-B) and Physogaleus contortus (C) - from Turtscher et al. (2021).
 
A new morphometric study by Turtscher et al. (2021) evaluated the taxonomy of different species of fossil tiger sharks in the genus Galeocerdo. This study resulted in the synonymy of many species, recognizing the following as diagnosable and senior synonyms: the extant Galeocerdo cuvier of course, Galeocerdo eaglesomei (Eocene), Galeocerdo clarkensis (Eocene), Galeocerdo mayumbensis (Miocene), Galeocerdo aduncas (Oligocene-Miocene), Galeocerdo capellinii (Pliocene). This study also resurrects Physogaleus contortus, formerly considered a synonym of Galeocerdo aduncas, through careful attention to the serrations: the teeth of Physogaleus contortus and probable lower teeth of Galeocerdo aduncas both have long narrow crowns, but the crown heel (behind the distal notch) is coarsely serrated in Galeocerdo aduncas but very finely serrated in Physogaleus - requiring some careful observations before an identification can be made.