Note: I wrote this a couple of years ago, before the new paper by Bakker et al. (2026) on fossil Orcinus from the North Sea. I'm elated that the text has held up so well - so well, in fact, that rather than update the text throughout, I've added a section on the new paper as an addendum. This version does not include much on Rododelphis and Pseudorca, and perhaps I can update it at some point.
Introduction
Just a few days ago, I made my first trip to Sea World as an adult as well as a marine mammal scientist. Setting aside the ethical issues associated with keeping enormous and highly intelligent cetaceans in captivity, it was my first time seeing killer whales - ever. I visited the park when I was a young boy, I think about five, but have no memories of the park whatsoever (I do, however, remember being terrified by the 'Monstro the Whale' ride at Disneyland during the same trip, fearing my parents were actually going to feed me to a whale - no wonder I ended up studying cetaceans). I saw "Free Willy" in 1993 (though it left less of an impact than Jurassic Park, for obvious reasons). So while I *may* have seen an orca as a kid, I don't remember it. I was quite surprised at how much science was presented in the orca show - and Sarah remarked on the lack of trainers ('performers') in the water during the show. If you recall, trainers were removed from the show after the 2010 death of trainer Dawn Brancheau - the third trainer killed by Tilikum, a large male orca that lived at Sealand in British Columbia and then later Seaworld in Orlando. I, and many others, have strong feelings about keeping certain marine mammals in captivity - certainly, not all who end up in captivity are a result of injuries deeming the individuals unreleasable - but on the other hand, Seaworld does have a long-standing and successful marine mammal hospital and rehabilitation program, and scientists at Seaworld do coauthor a number of peer-reviewed studies every year. Still, like any amusement park, it's not difficult to see the griftier side of things. In any event, I do hope to see orcas in their native environment some day - maybe whale watching in Puget Sound will be the best bet.
One of my shots from my trip to Sea World - one of the females, I seem to recall this one was "Orkid".
Killer whales, or orcas - are easily one of the most well-known, and well-studied modern species of cetacean, and their centerfold role at Seaworld, and movies like Free Willy - have certainly contributed to their celebrity status among whales (though they have recently shown up, and perhaps deservedly so, as predatory villains in animated penguin films alongside giant petrels and leopard seals). Orcas have a worldwide distribution, living in every ocean basin except for the high arctic - though they tend to be more populous/concentrated along continental shelves and specifically at higher latitudes. Different populations have different ecologies, and some slight external differences. The most extensively studied orcas are from the North Pacific, and are divided into three populations here: the fish-eating resident killer whales, the fish and shark eating offshore killer whales, and the transient killer whales, often referred to as Bigg's killer whales. In the Atlantic there are the fish-eating Type 1 killer whales and baleen-whale eating Type 2, and then in the southern Ocean, there are five types: Type A or Antarctic killer whales, large individuals that feed on baleen whales; slightly smaller Type D or subantarctic killer whales, possibly feeding on fish; and three types with gray instead of black and yellowish white patches, referred to as B1, B2, and type C - B1 and B2 feed mostly on seals and C mostly on fish. Most of these 'types' seem to cluster and form nice clades on phylogenetic trees generated from molecular datasets, suggesting a degree of lineage sorting within orcas. Recognition of this has even led some researchers to propose splitting up Orcinus orca into many species. In the past, many different species had been named for killer whales, and so for some ecotypes, it's best to identify the oldest available name for a particular ecotype - rather than proposing a new species. Just about two months ago, a paper came out (Morin et al., 2024) that proposed resurrecting the name Orcinus rectipinnis for transient/Biggs and Orcinus ater for residents (ironically, both names were coined by Edward Drinker Cope - who was most famous for his work in dinosaur paleontology, but made a bunch of very important early contributions to cetology and paleocetology). I won't get into whether or not these species are real, or if they should best be left as subspecies - on a philosophical level, I'm skeptical that any of these ecotypes can be identified from skeletal remains. This is of course not a valid scientific argument - we've known for a long time that there are many well-established extant cetacean species (especially other congeneric species within the Delphinidae - e.g. the Delphinus/Stenella complex) that are very difficult to pick apart even with complete skulls - but it's still a problem that bothers me. Perhaps we've grown complacent with conveniently having only a single species of Orcinus. But, that's not what we're here to talk about. This blog post is dedicated towards summarizing what we know of the evolutionary history of killer whales, and their fossil record.
The large male "Ulysses" showing off the formidable teeth of his species - from my recent trip to Sea World.
A brief note on the world's largest dolphin
Many people needlessly get hung up on the terminology of common names, and there is no shortage of folks correcting others on the common names of cetaceans. Killer whales are in fact dolphins - but they're also whales. They're whales by default, since it's in their damn common name - end of story. Anything named a whale is one. So please, enough with folks pushing up their glasses and starting with a "well, actually, they're not whales" - just shut up, nobody thinks you're cool. The truth is, whale and dolphin are not scientific terms in the first place. For a long while, most sightings of wild cetaceans were by whalers, and up until the early 19th century, there was considerable debate whether or not whales were fish or mammals, even playing out in court (Maurice v. Judd, 1818), and Herman Melville famously concluded that - after a remarkably honest and open presentation of the arguments for both ideas in his "On Cetology" chapter in his 1851 masterpiece Moby Dick - whales were in fact fish. So please recall the context in which these names were invented - systematics and phylogeny were but a glimmer in the eye of a generation of scientists not yet born.
Historically, dolphin - and porpoise - typically referred to any small cetacean with a 'beak' - e.g. the bottlenose of a bottlenose dolphin. Within the Odontoceti (toothed whales), whale was typically applied to any species without a beak - chiefly sperm whales and the "blackfish". Risso's dolphin (Grampus griseus), which is not black and also not terribly small (nearly as large as a pilot whale), and lacks a beak - is a puzzling exception. The "blackfish" include killer whales (Orcinus orca), pilot whales (Globicephala spp.), the false killer whale (Pseudorca crassidens), the pygmy killer whale (Feresa attenuata), and the melon-headed whale (Peponocephala electra). All are delphinids, have dark skin, and lack a beak. Curiously, the "beaked whales" were never called dolphins; I suspect because they're typically large. Lastly, recall that whale is applied also to baleen whales (Mysticeti), and scientists often use the term 'whales' to refer to 'cetaceans' in general. So, there's a couple different levels of terminology: all dolphins are whales, but not all whales are dolphins (a phylogeny-informed but essentially modern, post-hoc convention) and the strict common name based approach, with all of its historical baggage. The point is this: these terms, as historically applied, are somewhat meaningless: so don't go applying your own meaning where none has ever been applied systematically in the past. Killer whales are whales because they have it in the common name, and because they're cetaceans, as well as being toothed whales, and oceanic dolphins (Delphinidae). If you want to read more about what these names mean, I had a bit of a fun time during Covid writing an entire post about Whale v. dolphin v. porpoise, including the results of some intentionally misleading polls I posted on twitter (mind you, these were answered by my twitter followers, the cross-section of whom are generally, on average, reasonably zoologically informed).
What do we know about modern orcas? An extremely brief summary
Phylogeny. Killer whales are of course members of the family Delphinidae, or the oceanic dolphins. Delphinidae are the most diverse family of modern cetaceans, with 37 species. These include bottlenose, common, spinner, white-sided, snubfin, and humpback dolphins, along with the aforementioned Risso's dolphin and the curiously named right whale dolphins. Along with these are the "blackfish" (mentioned above). Killer whales used to be assigned to the Globicephalinae - after all, being large, beakless, and black in coloration is a pretty distinctive set of morphological features suggestive of common ancestry, right? In 1999, a molecular phylogeny by LeDuc et al. instead found that killer whales are the second earliest diverging lineage within the family and not closely related to any other delphinids. Instead, the Globicephalinae includes all other "blackfish", along with the tropical 'snubfin' dolphins, Orcaella spp., that had long been assigned to their own subfamily Orcaellinae, along with Grampus griseus, Risso's dolphin - formerly placed in the Delphininae along with a bunch of other species it didn't really resemble aside from just "it's also gray". When I first started reading about delphinid phylogeny, I was 1) amazed by this revelation that Orcinus was not closely related to the globicephalines and 2) equally amazed that Risso's dolphin was not considered a globicephaline. I mean, it looks like a gray pilot whale! (To be honest, more like a gray melon-headed whale, but who's counting). Based on this, the subfamily Orcininae was resurrected, containing only Orcinus. We'll come back to delphinid phylogeny later: once when I introduce some extinct orcinines, and then at the very end.
Skeletal/dental morphology. Killer whales have remarkably robust and distinctive skulls - so much that, if you came across their skeletal remains, they would be very easy to identify (you can't say the same about most of the smaller delphinids). They have rather a count of 10-14 large teeth (per quadrant) that are surprisingly anteroposteriorly compressed and have an oval rather than circular cross-section. These teeth are typically about 6-8 cm in length, or roughly three inches - about the size and proportion of a large human's thumb. While these teeth are pointed, they do not have any cutting edges - the tips are conical. The skull is somewhat asymmetrical (as in all other Delphinidae), and looks like a very beefy bottlenose dolphin skull that has been made to be quite wide; the skulls are quite large, about 70-110 cm in length - about a meter at the upper end (about three to three and a half feet long). For comparison, this is about double the length of a bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops*) skull, and the largest killer whale skulls are only about 20 cm shorter than that of "Sue" the T. rex. Orcas have robust snouts (rostra) that are thick and rather blunt, and relatively deep, robust mandibles - adaptations for high bite forces and for wrangling marine mammal prey. The periotic (aka petrosal), or inner ear bone, of Orcinus is extremely distinctive amongst odontocetes and has a massively inflated body and proportionally small cochlea. When you see an Orcinus periotic, you know it immediately. We'll come back to that later.
*Apologies in advance but Tursiops is going to be our baseline here, since 1) it's one of the most common delphinids (ecologically speaking), 2) it's a generalist so it's already a good point of comparison, eco-morphology wise and 3) it's the stereotypical dolphin most people are familiar with, though to be honest, I think most folks expect a bottlenose dolphin to be about 70-80% of the size they are in real life; I think most folks intuitively assume a bottlenose dolphin to be about two meters long, but in reality, they are typically about 2.5-3.5 meters (8-11.5 feet).
Side view of one of the orcas at Sea World - I suspect this one is also Orkid, one of their females.
External morphology. Aside from their vivid external coloration, killer whales have enormous oval-shaped pectoral flippers, the shape of which is dictated by a rather unique manus (hand skeleton) with digits that are widely splayed out. The dorsal fin is absurdly tall amongst other delphinids, but especially so in male orcas, boasting a two meter vertical triangular blade-shaped fin. Along with size differences between sexes, their striking dorsal fin makes killer whales one of the most sexually dimorphic of all delphinids (and let's be honest, cetaceans in general). Slight differences in the shape of the dorsal fin as well as the 'saddle' pigmentation behind it permit identification of wild orcas along the Pacific coast to ecotype. I imagine this is by experienced whale watchers and guides: the external differences of our Pacific ecotypes, to use a quote from my late Ph.D. adviser, are "much of a muchness" to me. (You could, however, say the same thing about virtually all of the skeletal differences between delphinids).
Body size, growth, and age. Adult killer whales generally approach lengths of 6-8 meters (20-26 feet) for males and slightly smaller sizes females at 5-7 meters (16-23 feet); males will attain masses of 5-6 tons, and 3-4 tons for females. Lengths of nearly 10 meters (32 feet) are occasionally reported. Calves measure about 2.5 meters (8') long at birth and weigh about 180 kg (400 lb); gestation takes about 15-17 months. Growth to sexual maturity is long - 7-16 years for females and 10-17 years for males. Orcas typically live for about 30 years but there are some cases exceeding 50 years, and less-well supported claims of nearly a century.
Underwater shot of the female 'Orkid' at Sea World, showing the incredible size of the oval-shaped pectoral flippers of Orcinus orca.
Ecology and feeding behavior. Different populations and ecotypes of killer whales have different feeding methods. Some of the fish-eating orcas from the North Atlantic will swim into schools of fish and stun fish by slapping their caudal flukes through baitballs - and then eat the unconscious fish (as shown in the BBC documentary Blue Planet). Offshore killer whales feed so often on pelagic sharks that their teeth get worn down by continuous abrasion by the enameloid-covered denticles in shark skin; these teeth are, somewhat horrifically, worn right down to the gumline. Ichthyologist Dr. Doug Long told me years ago that one skull with highly worn down teeth in the collections at California Academy of Sciences was hypothesized by staff to be evidence of care for geriatric individuals, and that other orcas must have been feeding it; or, that's what they CAS staff would tell folks getting a behind-the-scenes tour. Now it turns out that that individual was probably just an offshore orca. Orcas along the coast of Patagonia will swim right up onto the beach and bite unsuspecting fur seals and sea lions, pulling them into the water in one of the most spectacular predation events you will ever see in mother nature (this sort of footage deeply impacted me as a young naturalist - probably the closest you'll ever get to seeing something like a T. rex attacking prey. Awe-inspiring, and a bit like a grisly car accident: you feel like you shouldn't be watching, but you cannot look away). Some Antarctic killer whales will swim in parallel towards an ice floe with a seal on it, generating a wave that flows over the ice and knocks the seal into the water. And, perhaps the most incredible of all - the true whale-killing orcas will drown baleen and sperm whales to kill them, often just by swimming up and laying on top of their head to exhaust and eventually drown the whale; others have been observed ramming large prey to death. Killer whales tend to consume the tongue of baleen whales, and little else - leaving carcasses that are otherwise ~80% intact to float and sink. Orcas do not have teeth with cutting edges, or hands, so they have to shake apart large prey that they cannot swallow whole. And, as disturbing as it is fascinating, orcas have been observed capturing - but not killing - small marine mammals and then releasing the prey as 'practice' for juveniles. Lastly, orcas also harass and seemingly kill some prey for fun and play with the carcasses (or parts thereof) - in this way, killer whales are often compared with housecats. Which brings us to the next topic...
Intelligence, culture, and behavior. Like other cetaceans, orcas live in complex social groups called pods. Killer whale groups are matrilineal and led by matriarchs - the oldest female, along with her daughters and sons. These matriline groups are not considered pods themselves; matrilines, typically around 5-6 whales, rarely if ever separate for more than a few hours, and will group together to form larger pods. These pods may include a few different matrilines and separate for weeks or months. There are other, larger groupings as well: clans are groups of different pods with similar 'dialects' or similar vocalizations, and above this, are 'communities' - pods of killer whales that often associate freely but share no common dialect with one another. Molecular studies indicate that male orcas generally only mate with females from other pods. Killer whale pods have their own distinctive types of calls/vocalizations, and when mingling with other pods, use a different set that is thought to be more universally understood. Transient killer whales, which prey on marine mammals - are much more silent and generally do not vocalize while hunting, as most marine mammals can hear odontocete vocalizations underwater (I had heard this before, but this will never not creep me out). Killer whales have the second absolutely largest brain of all mammals - after sperm whales. Since we can't exactly give a cetacean an IQ test, we use encephalization quotient - essentially looking at the proportion of brain mass to body mass. There's basically a minimum amount of brain mass required just to 'run' a vertebrate body, and so anything beyond that initial mass is thought to be a rough measure of intelligence. It's imperfect, but it's all we've got at present - and conveniently, it works for fossils as well since we can estimate brain and body mass. Orcinus has an EQ of about 2.5 to 3.3 (3.3 according to our 2017 reanalysis of EQ in cetaceans), similar to many other delphinids (for comparison: bottlenose dolphin has an EQ of 3.5 (possibly up to 5 according to other analyses); poor archaeocetes like Dorudon and Zyghorhiza at 0.4-0.7; chimpanzees are around 2.5, and humans are at about 7-8).
There are countless stories of killer whales taking advantage of fishing practices to steal fish off lines and from nets, quickly figuring out bait-less decoy lines, and otherwise outsmarting all sorts of attempts by fishermen to fool orcas (and, to say nothing of their ability to learn complex routines for shows at places like Sea World). But, some of the most incredible are the stories of cooperative hunting between whalers and orcas - like "Old Tom", a large orca that basically worked with the Davidson family of whalers in Eden, New South Wales, Australia, every year for generations (the age of Old Tom is controversial, as the family claimed he was about 90 at death in 1930, but study of his teeth indicated an age of 35). The Davidsons had no ship, instead being a shore-based whaling station (I've seen a similar whaling station in New Zealand at Karitane, just a short drive north of Dunedin and U. Otago), and just used small boats for whaling. Old Tom would signal the whalers whenever he observed a baleen whale by slapping his tail on the water, and would literally take a rope attached to the front of the whale boat and tow the crewed boat out to the whale. The whalers would kill the baleen whale, and anchor the carcass; Old Tom and his friends would eat the tongue but leave the blubber alone, and the whalers would come back and harvest the bones, baleen, and blubber to be rendered into oil.
Given the adaptability of these whales and their high intelligence, it's no wonder that some misbehave in captivity and there are some that have been documented becoming aggressive, and aggression can even be targeted towards orcas that have stronger bonds with human trainers. Like I said, I have mixed feelings about places like Sea World.
The Fossil Record of Delphinids and the improbable early Miocene killer whale "Orcinus" meyeri
In order to really understand the fossil record of oceanic dolphins, and killer whales, there is a veritable ocean of 'bad identifications' one has to wade through in order to find genuine fossil occurrences. In what is almost certainly due to the familiarity of killer whales and other extant species, even to 19th century paleontologists, many fossil odontocetes with no clear resemblance to genera like Orcinus or Tursiops were assigned to these taxa. This is where we get oddballs like early Miocene records of Delphinus or Orcinus; in the Paleobiology Database, these sketchy records are frequently labeled with "Old ID". Back in those days, fragmentary remains were often uncritically assigned to extant taxa. During the late 19th and early 20th century, paleontologists would frequently mis-assign fossils or entire species to some roughly similar genus - later on realizing the species really belongs in its own genus or occasionally its own family. This is the paleontologist's version of "precise but not accurate". Philosophically, I understand this: early paleocetologists were attempting to be taxonomically conservative, and didn't really have much of a fossil record to go on. In extreme cases, this led to the assignment of dozens of species to wastebasket genera like Squalodon (30+ species) and Cetotherium (8+ species). One such example is "Orcinus" meyeri, first dubiously assigned to Delphinus by Meyer in 1859 (as Delphinus acutidens), and (re)named in 1873 by one of the first paleocetologists Johann Friedrich von Brandt which at face value, is represented by a big-ass dolphin jaw with large, single rooted teeth. However, it's from the early Miocene - extremely old. During the mid-19th century, we had no idea that delphinids are such a young clade. Instead, Othenio Abel suggested in 1905 that the fossil actually belonged to a sperm whale, something close to Physeterula dubusi. While he was apparently equivocal about the species level assignment, and quibbling over the genus assignment is warranted, I think Abel was right on the nose about sperm whale affinities. So, an early Miocene orca it is not.
Over the past 30 years, many fossils previously attributed to the Delphinidae have since been reassigned to other families, chief among these the Kentriodontidae (extinct early delphinoids). Old, imprecise records have been whittled down, leaving us mostly with Pliocene and latest Miocene records of the family. We now have a consensus that the Delphinidae is a relatively late diversification, with a few lineages present in the late Miocene of the North Pacific such as Eodelphinus and Norisdelphis from Japan and an unnamed but similar taxon from the Monterey Formation of the Laguna Hills in Orange County, currently on display at the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County. Most lineages within the Delphinidae likely branched off during the Pliocene and Pleistocene - more on that later. Before we get into bona fide killer whale fossils, what about other relatives within the clade Orcininae?
Plaster cast of the Hemisyntrachelus cortesii holotype skull and a referred mandible - from Bianucci (1996).
Mounted skeleton and in situ skeleton of Hemisyntrachelus cortesii from the Pliocene of Italy; from Freschi (2014).
Hemisyntrachelus - the giant bottlenose dolphin from the Mediterranean, North Sea... and Peru?
Hemisyntrachelus cortesii was first named from the Pliocene of Italy, by Fischer in 1829. This species was formerly known from a beautiful skull and mandible destroyed during World War 2, but fortunately high quality plaster casts of the specimen are still available for study. Giovanni Bianucci reported two recently discovered specimens in a 1997 paper, and also revised the taxon in his monograph on fossil Delphinidae from Italy in the first of his doctoral thesis publications in 1996. Hemisyntrachelus is superficially similar to Tursiops and has frequently been mistaken for it, or at times species of Hemisyntrachelus have been assigned to Tursiops. Tursiops truncatus has skulls that are approximately 40-50 cm in length, whereas Hemisyntrachelus cortesii has a skull approximately 60-80 cm in length; the rostrum is broader with wider premaxillae with parallel (rather than converging) edges, antorbital processes that are more robust with deeper antorbital notches, orbits placed further anteriorly (like Pseudorca and Orcinus), fewer and larger teeth (intermediate between Tursiops and Orcinus), a shorter mandibular symphysis, and a bunch of additional postcranial features. The teeth are quite interesting: Tursiops has a tooth count of 18-29 per quadrant, whereas Hemisyntrachelus has 14-16 proportionally larger teeth; in Orcinus, there are 10-14 very large teeth per quadrant. Hemisyntrachelus cortesii is known from skeletons that indicate a body length of 3.5-4 meters - quite a bit larger than most modern Tursiops truncatus (2.5-3 meters, roughly), and comparable in size to Orcinus citoniensis.
The holotype skull of Hemisyntrachelus pisanus. Photo by Ghedoghedo via Wikimedia Commons.
A second species, Hemisyntrachelus pisanus, was named from a specimen originally published in 1911 as Hemisyntrachelus cortesii. The skull is from a subadult with incompletely closed sutures, and is already roughly 70 cm in length - which suggest that it is a larger species than H. cortesii. Aside from this, it chiefly differs in having a somewhat longer rostrum and a straight mandible that has no ventral curvature, in which it somewhat more closely resembles Pseudorca crassidens. This species may have gotten up to five meters.
The rather nice holotype skull of Hemisyntrachelus oligodon from the Pisco Formation of Peru - from Pilleri and Siber (1989).
A third species, originally named Tursiops oligodon by Pilleri and Siber (1989) from the Pisco Formation of Peru, was later reassigned to Hemisyntrachelus by Post and Bosselaers (2005), given the large size and low tooth count of this specimen: it has 12 teeth per quadrant, and they are quite large; this species may be the most robust yet - though not the largest, with a skull length of only 62.5 cm, only slightly larger than Tursiops truncatus. It also happens to be the oldest - it's from the uppermost Pisco Formation, which is latest Miocene to early Pliocene in age (likely 5-7 Ma, according to Ochoa et al., 2021). Just a phenomenal specimen - and desperately needing a modern description with better photographic figures. Pilleri was prolific, but many of his published figures - to say nothing of his brief and often irrelevant descriptions - frequently leave much to be desired.
A bunch of additional specimens of Hemisyntrachelus including mandible and rostral fragments were reported from the Netherlands by Post and Bosselaers (2005) and by Bakker and Post (2020). Earlier work by Giorgio Pilleri hypothesized that Hemisyntrachelus was chiefly a Mediterranean taxon, radiating withn but not leaving that basin. However, the mandibular finds reported by Post and Bosselaers (2005) indicated that perhaps this taxon lived beyond the Mediterranean, and within the eastern North Atlantic. They pointed out that Tursiops oligodon was likely referable to Hemisyntrachelus (see above). This was supported and confirmed by the discovery of more complete and diagnostic remains by Bakker and Post (2020), who reported a number of rostral specimens including one that is basically half of a skull.
One other Pacific basin taxon, the Pliocene-Pleistocene delphinid Pseudorca yuanliensis - briefly named in a 1998 abstract from Plio-Pleistocene deposits in Taiwan. This specimen is pretty remarkable - there are a few images online, which I won't share out of politeness to the researchers who are still working on describing the material (apparently it took many years to prepare properly). It doesn't closely resemble Pseudorca, or the more recently described extinct false killer whale Rododelphis - but it does really look like Hemisyntrachelus. And, it's big - the skull is around 75 cm long. However, the name Pseudorca yuanliensis doesn't appear to satisfy the minimum requirements under the ICZN and is best treated as a nomen nudum for the time being, according to the first publication by my Otago labmate Cheng-Hsiu Tsai (et al., 2013).
Arimidelphis - the dwarf killer whale from the Pliocene of Italy
Just when I was discovering the paucity of genuine killer whale fossils during my first foray into 'whaleontology' as an undergraduate student, a new paper (at the time) by Giovanni Bianucci in 2005 named the small delphinid Arimidelphis sorbinii from upper Pliocene to lower Pleistocene (3.1-2.2 Ma) deposits in eastern central Italy. Arimidelphis is known from a relatively small skull, 25 cm wide at the orbit - roughly the size of a large Tursiops, and somewhat smaller than adult Hemisyntrachelus. What is unusual, however, are the Orcinus-like proportions of the skull: while incomplete, the rostrum does taper considerably and was evidently quite blunt; the antorbital process is also quite robust, like Orcinus. However, it has a higher tooth count - at least 17 teeth - and these are proportionally smaller than in Orcinus. There's also a nice forelimb, with a scapula very similar in morphology to Tursiops and Globicephala, and humerus and ulna similar to Orcaella, Grampus, and Orcinus. Bianucci (2005) argued for Orcinus-like raptorial feeding in Arimidelphis, noting that the hyoids aren't really expanded like in the suction feeding ziphiids - but clarified that the same can be said for Globicephala, which is quite obviously otherwise a suction feeding specialist. A robust mandible with a large coronoid is shared pretty much only with Orcinus and Pseudorca, suggesting macrophagy - despite being a 'small' delphinid (e.g. only Tursiops-sized). A more recent phylogenetic analysis by Citron et al. (2022) found Arimidelphis to instead be a globicephaline, and closely related to the extinct Pliocene delphinid Astadelphis gastaldii and the modern rough-toothed dolphin Steno bredanensis (which, surprisingly, shows up as a globicephaline in molecular analyses despite having a long rostrum).
Orcinus paleorca - a big tooth from the middle Pleistocene of Japan
Another early record was named Orcinus paleorca by the Japanese paleontologist Hikoshichiro Matsumoto in 1937, based on a single isolated tooth from the middle Pleistocene of Chiba Prefecture in Honshu (the biggest of the islands in Japan). This tooth is missing the crown as well as the base of the root, but is similar in size to extant Orcinus, albeit with a more round cross-section than seen in the extant specimens available to Matsumoto. Given that modern orcas vary a bit, I'd be willing to bet that it might actually fall within the range of variation of modern individuals. Either way, this specimen does appear to represent a genuine fossil of a killer whale - but is comically incomplete to be the holotype of a species.
Orcinus citoniensis, the small bodied proto-orca from the Pliocene of Italy
One of the earliest published records of Orcinus remains the only "real" species, and the only non-fragmentary fossil of Orcinus... period. Orcinus citoniensis is based on a partial skull, mandible, and postcranial skeleton from the upper Pliocene of Tuscany, Italy. This species was named in 1883 by Capellini, re-figured by Bianucci (1996), and then recently re-described using modern methods and standards by Citron et al. (2022). Orcinus citoniensis is rather small, with a skull roughly 60 cm long - the size of a large Tursiops - and with a somewhat narrower rostrum than modern Orcinus orca. There are 14 teeth per quadrant, at the upper limit for Orcinus orca, but the teeth are of course absolutely small: roughly 1 cm in diameter. As a result of the smaller body size, these teeth are actually slightly proportionally larger than in Orcinus orca. Like Orcinus orca, the teeth are anteroposteriorly compressed. The teeth are less emergent from their sockets, resulting in less of a shearing and interlocking configuration - making them more suitable for consuming fish rather than ripping apart larger vertebrate carcasses. Paralleling the narrower rostrum, the temporal fossa - the area of attachment for the jaw-closing temporalis muscles - is proportionally smaller, and suggestive of jaw muscle volume comparable to Tursiops. Lastly, tooth wear of Orcinus citoniensis is characterized by large apical wear facets but only on the anterior half of the teeth - more similiar to wear in generalist fish eating populations of Orcinus rather than those that feed on marine mammals (or, for that matter, the extreme wear seen in offshore shark-feeding populations/ecotypes). Microwear shows a lack of large grooves and pits in the tooth, and instead the surface is finely polished - suggesting feeding on fish rather than larger prey.* Critically, the holotype has a nearly complete vertebral column, which indicates that this species attained a length of 3.5 meters - about 11.5 feet - much smaller than adult female Orcinus orca, and about half the length of adult males. Still, a bit larger than most Tursiops truncatus, and similar in absolute size to Arimidelphis and Hemisyntrachelus.
*It is very important, however, to note that tooth wear is NOT evidence of an adaptation - which is anatomical. Tooth wear represents the history of a single individual, and individuals can do weird things. Recall, for example, that in the large sample of early dolphins in the genus Xenorophus sloanii, one individual had lost most of its tooth enamel and had widespread and rather extreme tooth wear. Is fish eating, or marine mammal eating the norm for O. citoniensis? Fish eating seems to be consistent with the adaptations seen in the skull, rather than inconsistent, so I think the former is likely.
Scattered fossil orca remains from Europe, the Pacific, and the Carolinas
A number of more fragmentary records of Orcinus are known and/or exist in museum collections and await study. One published example is another isolated tooth from Japan, reported by Kohno and Tomida (1993). This one is more complete and informative, and had previously been identified in the literature as Physeter (sperm whale). This tooth has an enamel crown, is anteroposteriorly flattened and oval in cross-section, and also critically has a wear facet from an upper tooth - precluding assignment to Physeter, which lacks functional upper teeth.
A couple of specimens from New Zealand are not yet published, but nonetheless tantalizing. A nearly complete skull in a concretion - still not yet prepared - was collected from Motunau in Canterbury on the South Island. Dating is poor, but likely to be from the younger, Pliocene part of the column; Motunau and Glenafric are generally considered to be middle Miocene through Pliocene. When I was at Otago during my Ph.D. I came across a massive, black Orcinus periotic, on long term loan to Ewan Fordyce; I inquired about publishing the specimen, and he expressed some doubts whether the collector would ever formally donate the specimen, and also indicated that it had been found in a tidepool in the Chatham Islands, where no Pliocene marine rocks exist; some informal early dating experiments yielded a surprisingly young age. Ewan thought the specimen was likely modern and stained black. Regardless, ten years later, I still think the specimen should be studied.
Similar gigantic periotics have been collected from the coast of the Carolinas. Two are from Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, and the third is from Onslow Beach, North Carolina. One of the Myrtle Beach specimens is unstudied, but donated to the Smithsonian. At one stage the collection was earmarked for disposal, but cooler heads prevailed and the specimen remains - though I'm uncertain whether it has been catalogued or not. The Onslow Beach specimen is the only one I have a photograph of, from the North Carolina Fossil Club field guide; this one remains in a private collection, though it is massive and certainly represents Orcinus, if not Orcinus orca. As with hundreds of beach-cast earbones found along the Carolina coast, the age is uncertain - though there are Pliocene and Pleistocene marine units that produce vertebrate fossils in the Myrtle Beach region. I'm less familiar with Onslow Beach, which typically produces Oligocene marine mammal material - there are specimens of Ankylorhiza, Agorophius, Xenorophus, and Eomysticetus from Onslow Beach, along with the holotype specimen of Albertocetus meffordorum. None of these specimens have been published on, other than being figured in the NCFC field guide.
Another rather old published fossil records of Orcinus consists of a tooth and a periotic attributed to Orcinus citoniensis, collected from the Red Crag of Suffolk in England, and reported by Richard Lydekker in 1877. The Red Crag is a well-known Pliocene unit that has produced an extensive cetacean earbone assemblage, and dates to roughly 3.7-1.9 Ma, straddling the Pliocene-Pleistocene boundary. Unfortunately, providing scale bars was not yet common practice and as I don't have a physical copy of the publication, "life size" doesn't mean a whole lot - meaning that assignment to O. citoniensis is not necessarily supported unless Lydekker examined the original specimen in person. According to Jonathan Geisler, the fractured periotic of O. citoniensis (not figured anywhere) apparently resembles a more typical, uninflated globicephaline periotic, unlike the massive hulk of a specimen from the Crag - suggesting, based on my knowledge (and without seeing the periotic of O. citoniensis myself) that the Crag taxon may not be O. citoniensis and likely represents something closer to Orcinus orca.
Did Killer whales cause the extinction of the giant shark Carcharocles megalodon?
This idea had been around for quite a while, but did not enter the published literature until it was mentioned, almost as an aside, in Lindberg and Pyenson (2006). It's a fantastic idea: killer whales are about half to two-thirds the size of the gigantic extinct shark C. megalodon (depending upon whose body length estimates for the shark you use), killer whales are of course extant, giant pack-hunting macrophagous apex predators, and the giant shark is dead - no matter how many times you come across silly videos or posts on social media asking the banal question "is megalodon really extinct?"
There are of course some problems with this: the only nominal extinct 'neospecies' of killer whale, and the only fossil killer whale where we can actually interpret much of its feeding morphology, is Orcinus citoniensis - which as discussed above, is much smaller, less robust, with a narrower rostrum and smaller jaw muscles - and with tooth wear evidence of fish-eating - a far cry from anything that could realistically compete with a giant shark (or even a large shark like the great white, Carcharodon carcharias). What's further relevant is that Orcinus citoniensis is the only good Pliocene record of Orcinus - and we just do not have Orcinus in any other ocean basin aside from the Mediterranean during the Pliocene when C. megalodon went extinct.
The stratigraphic record of well-dated late Neogene occurrences of Carcharocles megalodon on the Pacific coast of North America, with the likely extinction interval and modal date in red, period of marine mammal extinction/turnover in blue, and the rough age control for Orcinus citoniensis in purple. Modified from Boessenecker et al. (2019).
Which begs the question - when exactly did C. megalodon go extinct? An initial analysis compiled all sorts of fossil occurrence data for the species, and statistically concluded that C. megalodon most likely went extinct about 2 million years ago. However, while working on our own project (Boessenecker et al., 2019), we noticed that there were some problems with this dataset - old dates, poor dates, bad specimen provenance/provenience - and some missing occurrences. We cleaned it up quite a bit, fixing many dates, getting rid of bad datapoints, and adding a bunch from the west coast and others missed by the earlier team, and when we did, our results pointed towards an earlier extinction, around the early-late Pliocene boundary: a most likely extinction date of 3.5 Ma, with an earliest date of about 4, and a minimum date (e.g. absolutely, positively, dead as a doornail) of 3.2 Ma - altogether, not bad: an 800,000 year window of extinction. There's only one major problem with this - all fossil records of Orcinus date to after our "most likely" extinction date, and the only one that appears to overlap at all was a small-bodied fish eater, O. citoniensis. Perhaps more critically, Orcinus likely had nothing to at all with the extinction owing to a much bigger problem: pre-Pleistocene fossils of it are basically only known from the Mediterranean (a couple poorly-dated scraps from the North Sea exist; see above), and there are no Pliocene north Pacific, South Pacific, or western North Atlantic records. What killed off Carcharocles megalodon in those places? And, roughly at the same time?** After earlier studies suggested a biotic (e.g. competitive) cause for extinction rather than one mediated by physical environmental changes (e.g. cooling climate and geographic/oceanographic changes), we proposed that competition with the recently evolved great white shark (Carcharodon carcharias) may have driven the extinction - the two species overlap for about 1-2 million years in the Pacific basin before C. megalodon disappears completely. In the time being, no fewer than three studies have been published testing this hypothesis using zinc and phosphate isotopes, clumped isotope thermometry, and most recently, dental microwear - and two out of the three have found some evidence that Carcharodon and Carcharocles did overlap trophically (I find these studies testing our hypothesis to be deeply humbling, and make me feel like I've succeeded as a scientist). We ultimately concluded that Orcinus evolved into a giant apex predator after the extinction of C. megalodon, likely sometime during the Pleistocene (Boessenecker et al., 2019)***.
*Despite the Red Crag specimens reported by Lydekker (1877), I do also find it a bit surprising that no Orcinus specimens from the Belgian or Dutch Pliocene have emerged in ~two centuries of intense collecting effort.
**There's actually further work to do - if there is an increase in occurrence data for the last 5-6 million years, it would be interesting to further analyze the dataset and see if there's any evidence for a synchronous or asynchronous extinction of C. megalodon worldwide. Did it last slightly later in some regions? Or is that just a result of stratigraphic bias - e.g. there aren't any rocks of the right age in some basins?
***In the spirit of straight shooting - we did actually get a couple of things wrong. We mistakenly reported the teeth of O. citoniensis as being proportionally smaller than O. orca, and having a higher tooth count; the tooth count does fall at the upper limit of O. orca. Everything else, however - we were correct about: smaller body size, less robust skull/narrower rostrum.
Rododelphis, Pseudorca, molecules, and the Pleistocene evolution of the modern killer whale
Some clues as to the origin of modern, gigantic killer whales have emerged in recent years through reanalysis of Orcinus citoniensis (Citron et al., 2022) and the surprising discovery of a fossil false killer whale from Pliocene-Pleistocene age marine strata of Crete in the eastern Mediterranean. By the way, before we continue, I think we need to talk about the elephant - or giant delphinid - in the room here, and I'm sure you've picked up on it by now: a large number, and I'd wager to guess perhaps half (or even more), of the entire fossil record of cetaceans that can actually be assigned to the Delphinidae have been reported from the Plio-Pleistocene of the Mediterranean, the majority being from Italy. What's the deal with that? Extreme publishing bias? I really, really doubt that. My own work on the Pliocene of California suggests that delphinids are some of the most rare odontocetes - the majority of odontocete faunas are instead composed by phocoenid porpoises, albireonid dolphins, monodontid belugas, sperm whales, and of course, the lovely little dolphin Parapontoporia. Delphinids seem to be slightly more common in late Miocene through Pliocene aged rocks in Japan, but phocoenids still make up the bulk of the small odontocete fauna - like California. Published assemblages from Pliocene localities in the southern hemisphere are more spotty, but in the well-sampled assemblages from the Pisco Formation, there are quite a few phocoenids and a handful of delphinids - but delphinids similarly make up a minority of the small odontocete fauna. In Peru and California, there tend to be 1-2 taxa of small delphinids and at least one globicephaline (or, small orcinine, like Hemisyntrachelus). Matters are different in the western North Atlantic, represented by the delphinid-rich assemblage from the lower Pliocene Yorktown Formation from the Lee Creek Mine of North Carolina. In general, unless there are some very, very severe sampling bias issues - it appears that delphinids radiated within the Mediterranean, and possibly in the North Atlantic as well. More on their radiation below.
The holotype skull, teeth, earbones, and postcrania of the extinct Pleistocene false killer whale Rododelphis stamatiadisi and Pseudorca for comparison - from Bianucci et al. (2022).
The new false killer whale from Crete was named Rododelphis stamatiadisi by Bianucci et al. (2022). It is not small - it has a similar sized skull to Pseudorca crassidens, the extant false killer whale, probably around 60 cm, like Pseudorca. The rostrum is quite robust and wide, and has a tooth count (11 per quandrant) that falls within the range for Pseudorca - though it differs considerably from Pseudorca in having a shorter tooth row and much smaller teeth. Otherwise, the fossil has the same suite of hallmark macrophagous adaptations as Pseudorca. However, a tantalizing clue comes from a source of data rarely, if ever, reported for fossil marine mammals: gut contents. Five otoliths (ear stones) identified as codfish (Gadidae) were recovered from the specimen, with some evidence of acid etching indicating likely ingestion. These are deemed relatively rare otoliths, and are unlikely to have become concentrated in the sediment unless they were introduced as gut contents. The size of these otoliths indicates fish roughly 20-30 cm in length. Like the Citron et al. (2022) study (conducted in parallel), Bianucci et al. (2022) report tooth wear data from Rododelphis. The teeth have some weak facets from where the teeth interlocked, and some teeth have minimal apical wear facets - in general, indicating consumption of fish, which is consistent with the gut contents.
Bianucci et al. (2022) report the results of a morphometric and phylogenetic analysis combined into a phylomorphospace plot - basically plotting the number of teeth v. tooth diameter and deforming a cladogram to fit the points on the plot. The jist of it is that tooth size increases occurred in parallel on the tree leading to both Orcinus orca and Pseudorca crassidens, and Bianucci et al. (2022) and Citron et al. (2022) concluded that the gigantic size and other adaptations to macrophagy in these whales evolved quite recently - perhaps during the Pleistocene. Surprisingly, this happens well after the origin of truly gigantic baleen whales, and less surprisingly, after the extinction of C. megalodon as well (outlined above). But that makes some sense: C. megalodon was gone, providing vacant niche space, and perhaps Orcinus (and Pseudorca) "fished up" the food chain, becoming adapted to larger and larger prey, eventually permitting predation on giant cetaceans.
Rapid radiation of the subfamily Delphininae, illustrating the most rapid evolutionary paces of the entire family of oceanic dolphins (Delphinidae): much of the diversification of this subfamily may have occurred during the Pleistocene. On the upper right is a lineage through time 'battleship' plot, showing two different periods: an early phase of evolution with 1-2 new species per million years during the late Miocene reflecting the initial evolution of the oldest lineages within the family (1), followed by a delayed and much more rapid phase (2) where there are perhaps 3-5 new species/lineages per million years during the Pleistocene. From Bianucci (2013).
Delphinids seem to have undergone rapid cladogenesis over the past 10 million years, with many extinctions - for example, we only have one orcinine left today - Orcinus orca - but there were at least a handful of other species known from the fossil record, now gone. Many delphinids are still undergoing speciation, and so rapidly that an entire new species (Stenella clymene, the Clymene dolphin) has appeared recently completely via hybridization of two other species that just don't have much genetic distance (Stenella longirostris, the spinner dolphin, and Stenella coeruleoalba, the striped dolphin). Bianucci (2013) went so far as to propose that the majority of delphinid "neospecies" - extinct species placed in modern genera - are likely to be dubiously assigned*, and following future phylogenetic analysis, might likely be found to not have any relationship with the modern species. This may be validated by molecular clock analyses; McGowen et al. (2009) found that, out of the 33 branching events within the molecular calibrated tree for Delphinidae, 7 of these branching events occurred within the late Miocene (~10-5.3 Ma), 10 within the Pliocene (5.3-2.5 Ma), and 16 in the Pleistocene (2.5 Ma to now). In general, I find Bianucci's (2013) hypothesis to be 'disturbing' but he's got a good point: there are several delphinid species that have never been included in a phylogenetic analysis before.
*This would have the greatest effect on the Yorktown Formation assemblage reported by Whitmore and Kaltenbach (2008), who reported a ton of delphinids including two "neospecies": Stenella rayi, and Lagenorhynchus harmatuki, along with many additional delphinids identified only to the genus level including Tursiops, Stenella (a different form), Delphinus Pseudorca, and Globicephala.
Delphinidae have a geographically restricted fossil record, although rare, cryptic, or uncommon in upper Miocene and Pliocene marine deposits beyond the Mediterranean and North Atlantic - so perhaps it's no wonder why Orcinus has such a poor fossil record. But, why is it so limited? One answer is provided by molecular analyses. The current population of Orcinus orca has a common ancestor that likely lived between 150,000 to 700,000 years ago, according to molecular clock analyses (e.g. Morin et al., 2010), and possibly, if not likely, during Marine Isotope Stage 11 (Morin et al., 2015), about 500,000 years ago (a warm, "super" interglacial) - in other words, the modern population of killer whales radiated entirely during the middle to late Pleistocene, with the modern ecotypes diversifying during the last glacial and interglacial (e.g. last 20-40,000 years). While there are plenty of isolated late Pleistocene occurrences of marine mammals, there are perilously few marine mammal assemblages or even 'faunules' from the Pleistocene, limiting our ability to track faunal change between the much better sampled Pliocene record and the modern fauna. Why is the Pleistocene marine mammal record so terrible? Two things: 1) sea level was generally lower during the Pleistocene as a whole, resulting in deposits that are actually completely out on the shelf and still submerged under the ocean and 2) rapid glacioeustatic changes in sea level throughout the Pleistocene resulted in widespread erosion of these deposits. A third point, possibly related to point 1, is that 3) Pleistocene deposits are so young that in most places, they have not even been uplifted yet and so there is little natural erosion that would expose fossils (this is especially true on the east coast). Furthermore, on the Pacific coast, most of the Pleistocene marine units that have produced marine mammal remains have mostly yielded fossils of pinnipeds and sea otters, possibly because they reflect very shallow settings; in fact, the only deposits which have produced more than a couple of random cetacean bones are the middle Pleistocene San Pedro Sand and the Palos Verdes Sand of Los Angeles County; other units like the Port Orford Formation of Oregon and the Moonstone Beach Formation of Humboldt County have yielded mostly pinnipeds and sea otters.
Time-calibrated phylogenetic tree of modern killer whale ecotype groups - note that the numbers on the lower left are in thousands of years. The deeper nodes occurred during the early late Pleistocene, and many of the ecotypes we have today evolved during the late Pleistocene. From Morin et al. (2024).
At the end of the day, I think the rather meager fossil record of killer whales is a consequence of the rapid - but recent - evolution of Orcinus, in concert with the awful Pleistocene marine record. Simply put, Orcinus evolved during a time in which few good fossil records for any marine mammals exist - a "black box" as I've referred to it in the past. Where to go from here? More exploration of Pleistocene marine units is needed - they do exist, but they have barely been studied. I put in a grant application for fieldwork along the California and Oregon coast, surveying about a dozen different Plio-Pleistocene deposits on a grand Pacific coast road trip - but it was not funded. Perhaps I'll get my stuff together and try again. Now that we're back home on the left coast, such a trip is much more realistic!
Addendum: an early Pleistocene "modern" killer whale from the North Sea
I wrote this blog post in summer 2024, and 'banked' it for future publication - and, earlier this month, my Dutch colleague Hidde Bakker et al. published a new study reporting some fragmentary but nonetheless important specimens from the North Sea. In addition to the Pliocene and Pleistocene rocks that crop out along the margin of the North Sea, like the "crags" of East Anglia (e.g. Coralline Crag, Norwich Crag, Red Crag), the Lillo and Kattendijk formations of Belgium, and various marine layers in the shallow subsurface in the Netherlands - there are a host of fossils that have been dredged up from various submerged layers along the seafloor of the North Sea. Recall that the North Sea is all entirely continental shelf and a broad, shallow valley-like embayment no more than 50 meters deep forms the southern bite of the North Sea between Norfolk to the west and the Netherlands to the east. There are several stratigraphic units exposed on the seafloor, and so dating trawled specimens usually requires analysis of adhering sediment and the microfossils contained within.
The rather nice vertex fragment of the skull of Orcinus sp. from lower Pleistocene sediments from the bottom of the North Sea. From Bakker et al. (2026).
Bakker et al. (2026) report several gigantic delphinid specimens that quite clearly represent Orcinus to the exclusion of all other delphinids - including a rather nice vertex, a very large squamosal, a mandible fragment, and two fused atlas-axis complexes. The vertex is morphologically very close to Orcinus orca, and the few differences are likely ontogenetic. Most critically, it is very large, larger than all other delphinids. The squamosal is even larger, and interestingly differs in being proportionally shorter than in modern Orcinus. The mandible fragment is missing the lateral surface, exposing eight alveoli which accommodated very large teeth with long, straight roots just like extant Orcinus. Similarly, the symphysis is quite short, unlike the elongated symphysis in killer sperm whales. However, the alveoli of the fossil measure 3 cm in diameter, as opposed to 4-4.5 cm in extant Orcinus - suggesting that this early form still had some 'growing' to do, and I speculate that, with slightly smaller teeth, this orca may have had a somewhat higher tooth count (as seen in Orcinus citoniensis). The fused atlas-axis complexes are also large, and share various features only with Orcinus orca. Bakker et al. (2026) convincingly identify these specimens as Orcinus sp. Scaling of these specimens indicates that this early Pleistocene form was just as gigantic as modern killer whales, around 7-8 meters in body length (=22-26 feet) - and even in the upper size range of modern populations.
A very large squamosal of Orcinus sp. from lower Pleistocene sediments from the bottom of the North Sea. From Bakker et al. (2026).
One of these specimens had adhering matrix which produced fossil pollen indicating an age of 2.6-2.1 Ma, making these specimens early Pleistocene in age (and, possibly from the very last sliver of the Pliocene). As a result of this age - corresponding to the Gelasian stage of international usage - Bakker et al. interpret these finds as being derived from the "Westkapelle Ground Formation", which also produced the bizarre balloon-headed globicephaline Platalearostrum, fossils of the Tursiops-like orca relative Hemisyntrachelus (see above), as well as the walrus Ontocetus.
The enormous mandible fragment of Orcinus sp. from lower Pleistocene sediments from the bottom of the North Sea. From Bakker et al. (2026).
Overall, these tantalizing discoveries are somewhat older than the smaller Orcinus citoniensis from the Italian Pliocene, likely from the late Pliocene (though unfortunately there is some ambiguity, and Orcinus citoniensis may potentially be early Pliocene; no microfossils were observed in the matrix). This new study supports the notion that killer whales did not start out gigantic, and evolved large body size after evolving their distinctive skeletal morphology. However, in contrast to what I wrote above - their evolution towards gigantism seems to have happened quite early within the Pleistocene - achieving modern gigantic body size within only 1-1.5 million years of the giant shark Carcharocles megalodon going extinct. Further, this study underscores the point that our fossil record on land is biased against the early Pleistocene - these fossils were found on the seafloor, tens of meters below sea level. I look forward to more 'maritime paleontology' and its promise for answering questions that can't be answered from the rock record on dry land.
References/Suggested Reading
Bakker, H., & Post, K. (2020). New records of Hemisyntrachelus (Odontoceti, Delphinidae) from the late Pliocene or early Pleistocene of the southern North Sea. Cainozoic Research, 20, 109-120.
Bakker, H., Post, K., Munsterman, D.K., Hoekendijk, J.P.A., & Bianucci, G. 2026. A large orca from the lower Pleistocene of the southern North Sea Basin pushes back the origin of macropredatory behavior in the oceanic dolphins (Odontoceti, Delphinidae). PeerJ, 14:e21890.
Bianucci, G. (1996). The Odontoceti (Mammalia, Cetacea) from Italian Pliocene. Systematics and phylogenesis of Delphinidae. Palaeontolographia Italica, 83, 73-167.
Bianucci, G. (1997). Hemisyntrachelus cortesii (Cetacea, Delphinidae) from Pliocene sediments of Campore Quarry (Salsomaggiore Terme, Italy). Bolletino della Società Paleontologica Italiana, 36, 75-83.
Bianucci, G. (2013). Septidelphis morii, n. gen. et sp., from the Pliocene of Italy: new evidence of the explosive radiation of true dolphins (Odontoceti, Delphinidae). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 33, 722-740.
Bianucci, G., Geisler, J. H., Citron, S., & Collareta, A. (2022). The origins of the killer whale ecomorph. Current Biology, 32, 1843-1851.
Boessenecker, R. W. (2013). A new marine vertebrate assemblage from the Late Neogene Purisima Formation in Central California, Part II: Pinnipeds and cetaceans. Geodiversitas, 35, 815-940.
Boessenecker, R. W., Ehret, D. J., Long, D. J., Churchill, M., Martin, E., & Boessenecker, S. J. (2019). The early Pliocene extinction of the mega-toothed shark Otodus megalodon: a view from the eastern North Pacific. PeerJ, 7, e6088.
Citron, S., Geisler, J. H., Collareta, A., & Bianucci, G. (2022). Systematics, phylogeny and feeding behavior of the oldest killer whale: a reappraisal of Orcinus citoniensis (Capellini, 1883) from the Pliocene of Tuscany (Italy). Bolletino della Società Paleontologica Italiana, 61, 167-186.
Kohno, N., & Tomida, Y. (1993). Marine mammal teeth (Otariidae and Delphinidae) from the early Pleistocene Setana Formation, Hokkaido, Japan. Bulletin of the National Science Museum, Tokyo, 19, 139-146.
LeDuc, R.G., Perrin, W.F., and Dizon, A.E. 1999. Phylogenetic relationships among the delphinid cetaceans based on full cytochrome B sequences. Marine Mammal Science 15:619-548.
Lydekker, R. (1887). The Cetacea of the Suffolk Crag. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, 43, 7-18.
Matsumoto, H. (1937). A new species of Orc from the basal Calabrian at Naganuma, Minato Town, Province of Kazusa, Japan. Zoological Magazine, 49, 191-193.
McGowen, M. R., Spaulding, M., & Gatesy, J. (2009). Divergence date estimation and a comprehensive molecular tree of extant cetaceans. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, 53, 891-906.
Morin, P. A., Archer, F. I., Foote, A. D., Vilstrup, J., Allen, E., Wade, P., . . . Harkins, T. (2010). Complete mitochondrial genome phylogeographic analysis of killer whales (Orcinus orca) indicates multiple species Genome Research, 20, 908-916.
Morin, P. A., Parsons, K., Archer, F. I., Ávila-Arcos, M. C., Barrett-Lennard, L. G., Ellis, G. M., . . . Foote, A. D. (2015). Geographic and temporal dynamics of a global radiation and diversification in the killer whale. Molecular Ecology, 24, 3964-3979.
Ochoa, D., Salas-Gismondi, R., DeVries, T. J., Baby, P., Muizon, C. d., Altamirano, A., . . . Carré, M. (2021). Late Neogene evolution of the Peruvian margin and its ecosystems: a synthesis from the Sacaco record. International Journal of Earth Sciences, 110, 995-1025.
Pilleri, G., & Siber, H. J. (1989). Neuer delphinid (Cetacea, Odontoceti) aus der Pisco-Formation Perus. In G. Pilleri (Ed.), Beitrage zur Palaontologie der cetaceen Perus (pp. 167-175). Ostermundigen, Switzerland: Hirnanatomisches Institut der Universitat Bern.
Post, K., & Bosselaers, M. (2005). Late Pliocene occurrence of Hemisyntrachelus (Odontoceti, Delphinidae) in the southern North Sea. Deinsea, 11, 29-45.
Tsai, C.-H., Fordyce, R. E., Chang, C.-H., & Lin, L.-K. (2013). A review and status of fossil cetacean research in Taiwan. Taiwan Journal of Biodiversity, 15, 113-124.
Whitmore, F. C., & Kaltenbach, J. A. (2008). Neogene Cetacea of the Lee Creek Phosphate Mine, North Carolina. Virginia Museum of Natural History Special Publication, 14, 181-269.






























No comments:
Post a Comment